The Florida–Tennessee Football Rivalry: A Storied History
The Florida-Tennessee football rivalry is an American college football rivalry between the Florida Gators football team of the University of Florida and Tennessee Volunteers football team of the University of Tennessee, who first met on the football field in 1916. This gridiron clash has evolved into one of the most anticipated games in college football, marked by periods of dominance, national championship implications, and a complicated web of coaching connections.
Early Years and Sporadic Meetings (1916-1991)
The Gators and Vols have competed in the same athletic conference since Florida joined the now-defunct Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Association in 1910, and the schools were founding members of the Southeastern Conference in 1932.
Florida and Tennessee's football teams first met in 1916 when both schools were members of the Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Association. They each joined the Southern Conference in the 1920s and were founding members of the Southeastern Conference (SEC) in 1932. For many years, the SEC allowed schools to arrange their own conference schedules, which sometimes resulted in unusual or imbalanced conference slates that varied according to traditional opponents and each athletic department's travel budget. Between the cost and time required to travel by train and the SEC's lax scheduling oversight, the two schools met on the gridiron only thirteen times between 1916 and 1969.
Tennessee dominated the early series, winning their first 10 meetings with Florida over a span of 37 years (1916-53). The highlight of this period was a 1928 season-ending matchup between undefeated squads in Knoxville that the Volunteers won 13-12. Florida and Tennessee would not meet again for fourteen years, the longest gap in the series. They next faced off in the 1969 Gator Bowl.
In what would become a trend in the series, controversy swirled around the contest. By all accounts, the playing surface had been a muddy mess. In the final game in the playing career of Volunteer quarterback and future Hall of Fame coach Bobby Dodd, Tennessee defeated Florida in Jacksonville, 13-6. Buddy Hackman scored both of UT's touchdowns, one on a trick play devised by the senior quarterback. An account of Dodd's trickery: "Against Florida in 1930 he got his teammates in a huddle and told them about a play he had used in high school. When the ball was snapped, it was placed on the ground unattended. The players ran in one direction. The 9-1 SEC champion Vols and the 8-1-1 Gators were not initially on each other's schedule in 1969.
Read also: University of Georgia Sorority Guide
Tennessee won their first two clashes against Dickey's Gators, and Florida won the next two, including a 1976 victory in Gainesville that was their first home win against the Vols in four tries. Florida ran their win streak over Tennessee to four games (over nine seasons) with wins in Knoxville and Gainesville in 1984 and 1985 as they topped the SEC standings in both years. However, Florida would not be officially recognized for those championships, as the program was put on NCAA probation during the 1984 season due to violations committed under former coach Charley Pell. Though SEC's executive committee had initially ruled that Florida could keep their first ever conference championship, the university presidents later overturned the decision and vacated the title.
The SEC became a 10-member league in the late-1960s, and a new scheduling system had the Gators and Vols play seven times over the next 21 seasons. Tennessee and Florida rotated back onto each other's schedule in 1990, which was coincidentally the same year that former Florida quarterback Steve Spurrier returned to Gainesville as the Gators' new head coach. Spurrier had spent most of his youth in Tennessee, and his return to the state was marred by a 45-3 Vols rout in 1990, the largest margin of victory in series history.
The "Third Saturday in September" Era (1992-2023)
The Southeastern Conference (SEC) expanded to twelve universities and split into two divisions in 1992, and Florida and Tennessee were placed in the SEC's East Division and began to meet annually on a home-and-home basis. The matchups were often early in the season, giving rise to the Third Saturday in September nickname. The rivalry quickly blossomed in intensity and importance over the 1990s and early 2000s as both programs regularly fielded national championship contending teams under coaches Phil Fulmer of Tennessee and Steve Spurrier of Florida.
One result of the SEC's 1992 expansion and split into divisions was the beginning of an annual match-up between Florida and Tennessee at a time when both programs rose to national prominence. Their first match-up as permanent opponents in 1992 helped to sow the seeds of rivalry, as the underdog Vols beat the defending SEC champion Gators in Neyland Stadium. Fulmer had been serving as UT's interim head coach while Johnny Majors recovered from heart problems, but his team's upset of the Gators helped to secure him the permanent position and brought about a decade of games in which the rivalry was one of the key match-ups of every college football season.
Florida and Tennessee played on the third Saturday of September almost every year from 1992 until the SEC expanded again in 2024, giving the rivalry its nickname. In many of those seasons, it was the first significant challenge of the season for one or both teams, with the winner gaining a key advantage in the race for a berth in the SEC Championship Game.
Read also: History of the Block 'M'
The rivalry held national championship implications over each of the following seasons, with both teams entering the contests ranked in the top 10 every year. Though they were not always the favorite, Florida won five straight against Tennessee from 1993 to 1997, winning four SEC titles and a consensus national championship in 1996. The 1994, 1995, and 1996 contests featured match-ups between starting quarterbacks Danny Wuerffel and Peyton Manning, who never beat Florida during his celebrated college career. But though Florida beat Tennessee in 1997, upset losses to LSU and Georgia propelled Tennessee to their own SEC championship in Manning's senior year. Tennessee broke Florida's winning streak in 1998 with a 20-17 overtime win and went on to win their second straight SEC championship and a national championship. During the 1990s, Florida and Tennessee combined to win eight conference and two national championships, and either the Gators or the Volunteers represented the SEC East in each of the first ten SEC Championship games. Both teams were ranked in the top 10 for eight out of their ten contests during the decade, and neither team ever entered their rivalry game ranked lower than No. 15.
Florida began the next decade with a 27-23 victory in Knoxville in front of a national record crowd of 108,768 fans. During the following season, the September 11 attacks postponed all NCAA Division-I football games that were scheduled to be played on the following Saturday. The Florida and Tennessee match-up was rescheduled for December, and the Vols upset the Gators in Gainesville, winning on Florida Field for the first time since 1971. Steve Spurrier left Florida for the NFL after the 2001 season, but two trends in the rivalry continued in 2002: both teams were ranked in the top 10, and new Florida coach Ron Zook led the Gators to another win in Knoxville. However, both teams stumbled later in the season, and for the first time ever, neither would represent the SEC's Eastern Conference in the SEC Championship Game. For the first time since the division rivalry began 11 years earlier, the 2003 match-up featured UF and UT teams that were each ranked out of the top 10 (UT No. 12, UF No. 17), and the game was relegated to a noon kickoff on CBS. Tennessee pulled away in the second half to win 24-10 for their second victory in Gainesville.
Ron Zook was fired during the 2004 season, and new Gator coach Urban Meyer put an emphasis on defending their home turf. Florida's 16-7 home win over Tennessee in 2005 helped to revive the program and started a Gator win streak in the rivalry that would span over a decade. Meyer's Gators beat Fulmer's Volunteers again in 2006 and 2007, and while Florida was SEC and national champions in 2006, Tennessee reached the SEC championship game in 2007. Florida won 30-6 in Knoxville in 2008 on their way to another SEC and national championship season. Lane Kiffin replaced Fulmer as Tennessee's coach in 2009.
Urban Meyer left Florida after the 2010 season, and while the program suffered through sub-par seasons under coach Will Muschamp (who was the Gators' coach from 2011 to 2014) their win streak over Tennessee continued during the first half of the decade. The Volunteers simultaneously suffered through some sub-par seasons of their own under coaches Derek Dooley (Tennessee's coach from 2010 to 2012) and Butch Jones (who arrived in 2013). The Gators ran their series win streak to eleven with a 28-27 comeback win in Gainesville in 2015, the first year under newly appointed head coach Jim McElwain. The 2016 and 2017 would also feature second half comebacks.
While the rivalry was still important to both schools, it lacked its previous national impact and attention during the first half of the decade. In 2013, both Tennessee and Florida failed to qualify for a bowl game during the same season for the first time since 1978. Both programs showed glimmers of improvement in the middle of the decade under coaches McElwain and Jones. Florida made back to the SEC Championship Game in 2015 and 2016, and both Florida and Tennessee were ranked in the AP top 25 coming into their 2016 and 2017 meetings. However, both the Gators and Vols faded to losing records in 2017, and both programs dismissed their once-promising head coaches before the end of the season.
Read also: Legacy of Fordham University
Florida's series win streak grew to five before Tennessee won in Knoxville in 2022 in what marked the first time in six years that both teams came into their rivalry game ranked in the AP top 20. Florida upset the #11 Volunteers in 2023 to extend their home winning streak in the series to ten games.
Coaching Connections and Program Intertwining
Though it is common for college coaches to switch allegiances as their careers progress, Tennessee and Florida's football programs have had a remarkably complicated web of personnel connections over the years, mostly centering around Doug Dickey. Dickey was raised in Gainesville, where his father was a professor at UF, and he walked on to Florida's football team under head coach and athletic director Bob Woodruff, who had played football at Tennessee under coach Robert Neyland. In 1960, Woodruff was replaced as Florida's football coach and athletic director by fellow UT alumnus Ray Graves. Graves was born and raised in Knoxville and was a captain on Tennessee's 1940 team under Coach Neyland. Woodruff returned to Tennessee after leaving Florida and became UT's athletic director in 1963 following the death of Neyland. One of his first major decisions was to hire his former player Doug Dickey as Tennessee's head football coach. Dickey enjoyed several years of success at Tennessee, leading the Vols to two SEC championships and five straight bowl appearances. He controversially returned to Gainesville after accepting an offer to become Florida's head coach only days after the Gators and Volunteers met in the 1969 Gator Bowl. Dickey replaced Ray Graves, who had unexpectedly retired from coaching after the 1969 season to become UF's full-time athletic director and was instrumental in choosing Dickey as his successor.
In 1978, Doug Dickey gave Steve Spurrier his first opportunity to coach when he hired the former star player as an offensive assistant. In 1985, Dickey returned to Knoxville to become UT's athletic director, replacing the retiring Bob Woodruff. Dickey named Phil Fulmer as Tennessee's head coach in 1992, setting up the intense Spurrier/Fulmer rivalry of the 1990s. Steve Spurrier returned to his alma mater in 1990 to become the Gators' head football coach. In yet another link between the programs, Spurrier had been a star quarterback at Science Hill High School in Johnson City, Tennessee during the early 1960s. Although Knoxville is nearby, he did not seriously consider attending UT because he was an excellent passer and the Vols ran a single-wing offense at the time which featured a running quarterback. Instead, he would choose to return to the state of his birt…
The Rivalry Today
Both programs changed coaches again early in the decade, with Josh Heupel taking over at UT in 2021 and Billy Napier at UF in 2022. Tennessee head coach Josh Heupel is 1-2 against the Gators since he was hired in 2021.
As long-time members of the same conference, Tennessee and Florida have long competed in many other sports besides football. Men's basketball in particular became a heated rivalry for a time in the mid- to late-2000s, when coach Bruce Pearl's Volunteer squads challenged coach Billy Donovan's national championship-winning Gator teams for supremacy in the SEC's Eastern Division. However, the basketball rivalry cooled after Pearl was fired in 2011 and Donovan left Florida for the NBA in 2015.
While there may not be divisions in the SEC anymore, two former eastern division opponents are facing off this weekend as Tennessee will be playing host to the Florida Gators. Given that they used to be in the same division, there is a lot of history between these two programs, so let's take a look at some of the recent history between them. Right now, Florida owns the overall series record as they are 31-21 against the Volunteers all-time. Tennessee has won just one game out of the last seven matchups and has only won twice in the series since 2005. That includes last year's game when the Gators defeated Tennessee in the Swamp by a final score of 29-16.This year's game is leaning in the favor of the Volunteers, as Tennessee is a 15-point favorite according to draft kings. However, this matchup has been decided by 15 or more points just four times since 2012. This year will mark the 54th clash between these two SEC foes and the 34th consecutive season they’ve faced off. Although the game is a must-watch nowadays, the two didn’t have much of a rivalry in their early years. They played 21 times between 1916 and 1992 when the SEC expansion took place. The SEC expansion in 1992 completely changed the course of this rivalry. It split the SEC into two divisions - East and West. In the modern era, Florida has decimated Tennessee.
After another frustrating loss Saturday night at Ole Miss 34-24, Florida returns home for the final two games of the season against No. Ben Hill Griffin Stadium has proven to be a house of horrors for the Volunteers for more than two decades. Tennessee has not beaten the Gators in Gainesville since 2003, but will get another crack this week as slight road favorites. While the results did not go Florida’s way, the Gators held their own in that one, especially after former quarterback Graham Mertz went down with an injury and DJ Lagway was inserted. After being benched in the first half against Kentucky, Lagway responded with a stronger outing against Ole Miss, completing 16 of 31 passes for 218 yards and a touchdown. “Put us in a position to where we were at,” Gators interim coach Billy Gonzales said. “Obviously, got to continue to make great decisions. “The message is going to be the same. Go back, gather up, get ready to work, continue to work hard. And again, we’ve got a really good group of players,” Gonzales said.
tags: #university #of #florida #vs #tennessee #football
