A Legacy Forged in Steel: A History of Pitt University Football Coaches

The Pittsburgh Panthers football team boasts a rich and storied history, dating back to its humble beginnings in 1889 when the University was still known as the Western University of Pennsylvania (WUP). From those early, disorganized games to national championships and legendary coaches, Pitt football has carved a significant place in the landscape of American college football.

The Genesis of a Program

The football program started in 1889, but it was an informal start. The team was organized by quarterback Bert Smyers and center John Scott, who themselves were just learning the sport. Alongside 12 other players, including the mascot, the team played a single game that first season, losing to Shadyside Academy. The following year, they played three games, achieving a 1-2 record.

Early Coaching and Rivalries

In 1893, Anson Forney Harrold, a former football player from Franklin and Marshall College and Princeton University, became the first official coach for WUP. This year also marked the first game against Penn State, a contest Pitt lost 32-0. Two years later, the inaugural game against West Virginia took place, which would later become known as the "Backyard Brawl," with Pitt losing 8-0.

The Dawn of Dominance

The 1904 season marked a turning point for WUP, as the team completed its first undefeated season, finishing 10-0. This accomplishment signaled the program's growing potential.After WUP moved from Observatory Hill in Allegheny City to Oakland, the University of Pittsburgh was established. As Pitt, the football team had seven more undefeated seasons. The Panthers had 17 seasons where they were one win away from being undefeated. These accomplishments were achieved through strong coaching, players, and teamwork.

The Warner and Sutherland Era: A Golden Age

Pitt has been fortunate being home to two coaching legends: Glenn Scobey "Pop" Warner and John B. “Jock” Sutherland. The program's success is largely attributed to the leadership of legendary coaches like Pop Warner and Jock Sutherland.

Read also: A Guide to Pitt University

Under Warner’s leadership (1915-1923), the Panthers achieved an impressive record of 60 wins, 12 losses, and 4 ties. He would also coach three Pitt teams to championship seasons (1915, 1916, and 1918). The 1916 team was special considering that playing under Warner that season were future Pitt legends John Bain “Jock” Sutherland (future Panthers football coach) and Henry Clifford “Doc” Carlson (future Pitt Panthers basketball coach).

A natural replacement for Pop Warner was Jock Sutherland, Warner's former All-American guard. Sutherland's second season kicked off the Panthers' first in the newly constructed Pitt Stadium and saw the team achieve an 8-1 record and win the 1925 Eastern Championship. One of the greatest back-to-back stretches in Pitt football history occurred during the 1936 and 1937 seasons which featured Heisman Trophy candidate and Hall of Fame running back Marshall Goldberg.

Jock Sutherland coached the Panthers from 1928 to 1934 and achieved an impressive 111-20-12 record. He led the Panthers to four Rose Bowl appearances, five national championships, and seven eastern championships. Sutherland also had the talents of the “Dream Backfield" (1936-1938) comprised of John Chickerneo, Dick Cassiano, Harold Stebbins, and Marshall Goldberg.

All-American Lineage

Three Pitt players gained entry into the All-American ranks under Warner: J. Huber "Hube" Wagner (1913), Robert “Bob” Peck (1915), and James Hernon (1915). Later inductees included Pitt football greats George “Tank” MacLaren, Jock Sutherland, Marshall Goldberg, Bill Daddio, Mike Ditka, Tony Dorsett, Matt Cavanaugh, Hugh Green, Bill Fralic, and Larry Fitzgerald, to name a few. The Panthers have had at least 88 players named to the All-American ranks.

Breaking Barriers: Bobby Grier and the 1956 Sugar Bowl

The Pitt Panthers won a major victory off the field during the 1956 Sugar Bowl. Pitt may have lost the game to Georgia Tech, but the color barrier would be forever broken with the courage of Panthers full back, Robert “Bobby” Grier, who became the first African American to play in the Sugar Bowl in New Orleans on January 2, 1956. The Governor of Georgia strongly opposed Grier's participation in the game, as did the Board of Trustees from Georgia Tech, who claimed that Georgia Tech would elect to forfeit the game if Grier was not benched. Nonetheless, Grier had strong support of his teammates and the University of Pittsburgh, who vowed "No Grier, no game." Support for Grier also came from students and football players from Georgia Tech, who protested strongly against a forfeit and succeeded in seeing Grier take to the field in New Orleans.

National Championship Glory

The Pitt Panthers have won nine national titles, three under “Pop” Warner, five under Jock Sutherland, and one under Johnny Majors, the two-time Panthers coach (1973-1976 and 1993-1996). The 1976 team under Majors not only was undefeated, but included Tony Dorsett, Matt Cavanaugh and a Sugar Bowl victory.

The Pittsburgh Panthers' national championship claims are concentrated in two primary eras under legendary coaches Pop Warner and Jock Sutherland, with a singular modern highlight in 1976, reflecting periods of dominant play that elevated the program's national profile. The program's lone post-World War II claim arrived in 1976 under Johnny Majors, with a flawless 12-0 record culminating in a 27-3 Sugar Bowl rout of Georgia, earning unanimous consensus from the AP Poll and Coaches Poll.

Conference Play and Modern Success

The Pittsburgh Panthers football program has achieved notable success in conference play since joining organized conferences, particularly during its Big East tenure from 1991 to 2012 and in the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) since 2013. In the Big East, the Panthers secured a share of the 2004 conference championship under head coach Walt Harris, finishing 8-0 in conference play and earning a Bowl Championship Series berth to the Fiesta Bowl. They repeated as co-champions in 2010 under Dave Wannstedt, tying with Connecticut and West Virginia at 5-2 in league action, which led to a victory in the Meineke Car Care Bowl.

Transitioning to the ACC, Pitt has excelled in the Coastal Division, capturing the title in 2018 and 2021 under head coach Pat Narduzzi. The 2021 season culminated in the program's first outright ACC championship, with an 11-2 record and a 45-21 victory over Wake Forest in the conference title game, followed by a Peach Bowl win against Michigan. In 2018, the Panthers reached the ACC Championship Game after winning the division but fell to Clemson, yet advanced to the Cotton Bowl, resulting in a defeat.

Hall of Fame Coaches

Several former Pittsburgh head football coaches have been inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame, recognizing their national impact and contributions to the Panthers' legacy of excellence. Glenn "Pop" Warner, who coached from 1915 to 1923, was inducted in 1951 for his innovative strategies that helped build early program dominance. Jock Sutherland, at the helm from 1924 to 1938 and 1945 to 1946, joined him in the class of 1951, honored for leading Pitt to multiple unbeaten seasons and national recognition. Clark Shaughnessy (1943-1945) was enshrined in 1968, celebrated for his single-wing offensive expertise during World War II-era success. Johnny Majors (1973-1976, 1993-1996) rounded out the group in 1987, lauded for his 1976 national championship season and broader influence on college football.

Read also: Faculty at Pitt CC

The Early Years of Pitt Football Coaching (1890-1914)

The Pittsburgh Panthers football program began informally in the late 19th century, with the first interclass games played in 1890 under student management, lacking a formal head coach. These early teams competed sporadically, focusing on basic organization and local rivalries, compiling an overall record of 8-10-0 across the seasons of 1890-1892 and 1894 without designated leadership.

Anson Harrold served as the first officially named head coach in 1893, guiding the team to a 1-4-0 record during a season marked by defeats against regional opponents. J.P. Linn took over in 1895, posting a 1-6-0 mark while introducing rudimentary offensive and defensive strategies to a still-developing roster. The following year, George W. Hoskins (1896) emphasized physical training and conditioning, resulting in a 3-6-0 record that showed incremental improvement in team durability.

Progress accelerated in the late 1890s and early 1900s. Fred A. Robison coached from 1898 to 1899, achieving the program's first winning record at 8-3-2 through consistent play against Western Pennsylvania teams. Roy Jackson in 1900 improved scheduling against stronger foes, ending with 5-4-0. Wilbur Hockensmith's 1901 season produced a near-undefeated 7-2-1 outcome, boosted by strong home performances. Fred Crolius focused on defensive schemes in 1902, compiling 5-6-1 despite a transitional year. Subsequent coaches built on this foundation. Edgar Wingard innovated with new play designs in 1906, finishing 6-4-0. John A. Moorhead navigated tough Eastern competition in 1907, recording 8-2-0. Joseph H. Thompson, a College Football Hall of Famer, coached from 1908 to 1912, amassing 30-14-2 while establishing key rivalries such as with Penn State and laying the tactical bedrock for the program. Joseph M. Duff, Jr., led an undefeated streak across 1913-1914, posting 14-3-1 and elevating Pitt's reputation regionally.

The Mid-Century Era (1924-1972)

The mid-century era of Pittsburgh Panthers football, from 1924 to 1972, began with unparalleled success under Jock Sutherland but transitioned into a period of challenges influenced by World War II, postwar adjustments, and shifting competitive dynamics in independent play. Charley Bowser (1939-1942) took over with a 14-20-1 record (.414 winning percentage) across four seasons, facing disruptions from World War II that depleted rosters and limited scheduling. Wes Fesler (1946), another College Football Hall of Famer (inducted 1954), served one season with a 3-5-1 record (.389 winning percentage) as the program transitioned back to full peacetime operations. Mike Milligan (1947-1949) guided the Panthers through rebuilding with a 13-14-0 record (.481 winning percentage) over three seasons, prioritizing recruitment and stability after the war. Dave Hart (1966-1968) oversaw a difficult stretch with a 3-27-0 record (.100 winning percentage), representing one of the lowest points in program history amid recruiting woes and competitive pressures. Carl DePasqua (1969-1972) concluded the era with a 13-29-0 record (.310 winning percentage) over four seasons, grappling with the final years of independence and setting the stage for future realignment.

The Modern Era (1973-Present)

The modern era of Pittsburgh Panthers football, spanning from 1973 to the present, has been characterized by the program's integration into major conferences such as the Big East (1991-2012) and the Atlantic Coast Conference (2013-present), alongside navigating recruiting challenges, NIL dynamics, and postseason opportunities in an increasingly competitive landscape. This period saw a mix of resurgence under early coaches like Johnny Majors and Jackie Sherrill, periods of transition and inconsistency, and more recent stability with bowl berths and division titles.

Johnny Majors, who had been an assistant under Majors, succeeded Majors as head coach at Pitt. Under Sherrill, the winning continued with a 9-2-1 record and Gator Bowl win in 1977 and an 8-4 record in 1978. Sherrill stockpiled future NFL talent including Pittsburgh's own quarterback Dan Marino, Hall of Fame inductee Russ Grimm, and Outland Trophy winner Mark May. Sherrill also molded a devastating defense that was anchored at the defensive end position manned by Hall of Fame inductee Rickey Jackson and Heisman Trophy runner-up Hugh Green, who had the highest finish in the Heisman voting by a defensive player until 1997. 1979 began a string of three straight seasons with 11-1 records. However, an early loss at North Carolina in 1979, a midseason loss during a driving rainstorm at Florida State in 1980, and a devastating season-ending defeat at the hands of rival Penn State in 1981 prevented those teams from clinching an AP or Coaches poll national championship. In each of these three seasons, Pitt rebounded to win a bowl game: the Fiesta, Gator, and Sugar Bowls respectively. Sherrill's teams at Pitt are considered by some to be among the most talented in Pitt and college football history. The 1980 Pitt team alone featured seven first round draft picks, 23 players who went on to start in the NFL, seven others who played in the NFL, and one player each who played in the CFL and the USFL.

Pitt continued success in the second half of the 1980s under head coach Mike Gottfried, and in 1991, joined the new Big East Football Conference, thus ending its history as a football independent, however coaching changes led to its football fortunes turning for the worse. In 1993, the university again looked to its past and brought back Johnny Majors. However, recruiting had fallen off significantly, and the quality of Pitt's football facilities had fallen behind those of its competition.

Walt Harris replaced Majors in 1997 and took Pitt to the 1997 Liberty Bowl in his first season. At the same time, the university administration began addressing the facility situation starting with the opening of a football practice facility, the UPMC Sports Performance Complex. In lieu of much-needed but cost-prohibitive renovations to modernize Pitt Stadium, the administration made a controversial decision to move home games to the newly proposed North Shore stadium, later named Acrisure Stadium, and to demolish Pitt Stadium. 1999 was the final season for the Panthers in Pitt Stadium, which had served Pitt for 75 seasons. Behind an increasing number of talented players, led by Biletnikoff Award winner Antonio Bryant, Pitt including a 12-0 defeat of rival Penn State. Additional bowl games and national rankings followed over the next four seasons. Overall Harris led the Panthers to a bowl game in six of his eight seasons, including five consecutive bowl games from 2000 through 2004, with bowl victories in 2001 and, led by Biletnikoff and Walter Camp Award winner Larry Fitzgerald, in 2002. Harris also led Pittsburgh to a share of the Big East Conference championship and a Bowl Championship Series (BCS) Fiesta Bowl bid in 2004. Harris was named the Big East Conference Coach of the Year in 1997 and 2004, and he was the AFCA Region I Coach of the Year in 2002. Over his eight years at Pitt, from 1997 to 2004, Harris compiled an overall record of 52-44.

Dave Wannstedt, a Pittsburgh area native and former Pitt player, succeeded Harris as Pitt's head coach on December 23, 2004. Known for his recruiting…

tags: #pitt #university #football #coaches #history