Waldorf Education: Weighing the Pros and Cons of a Unique Approach
Waldorf education, based on the philosophy of Rudolf Steiner, presents a unique approach to learning that emphasizes the "whole child." With a growing number of Waldorf schools and kindergartens worldwide, parents are increasingly drawn to its focus on creativity, hands-on learning, and a connection with nature. However, this educational model also has its drawbacks. This article will explore the pros and cons of Waldorf education to help parents make informed decisions about whether it's the right fit for their family.
The Waldorf Approach: A Holistic Education
Waldorf education stems from the ideas and teachings of Rudolf Steiner, an Austrian educator and philosopher who founded the first Waldorf school in Stuttgart, Germany, in 1919. Steiner's vision centered on nurturing the "whole child," diverging from the predominantly academic focus prevalent in German schools at the time.
Today, the Alliance for Public Waldorf Education reports nearly 1,200 Waldorf schools and over 1,900 Waldorf kindergartens across the globe. In the United States alone, there are approximately 130 Waldorf schools, encompassing both public and private institutions. The Association of Waldorf Schools of North America (AWSNA) describes its schools as offering a "developmentally appropriate, experiential, and academically rigorous approach to education."
Core Principles
Waldorf schools are built upon the philosophy that imaginative and practical, hands-on work is the most effective way to promote learning. Children are introduced to lessons through music, visual arts, dance, writing, and myth. Classical mythology, cultural folk and fairy tales, and religious images are common in Waldorf classrooms.
Steiner believed that schools should introduce subjects at certain stages of development. Experts in Waldorf education emphasize teaching the whole child. A main lesson is taught in a block of time lasting for several weeks. Creative arts like drawing, painting, language studies, music, and drama support the main lesson and give students a variety of avenues to learn the material. Students then continue an exploration of the lesson through movement and motor skills, with activities like physical education, building, dance, and gardening.
Read also: The Waldorf Approach
The model is a thematic approach. Students immerse in their learning and have time to adequately explore and understand the content. This allows different entryways for each student to access material, says Kimberly Vachon, a Waldorf school alum and a former Waldorf teacher who is now doing doctoral work in education at the University of California-Santa Cruz. Students have to really engage and participate in their education.
The Learning Environment
Parents touring a Waldorf school will notice classrooms with open space, supplies made from natural materials, natural light, and a palette of muted colors. Students might participate in whole-group lessons directed by their teacher and move on to collaborate with peers while they explore the lesson topics with materials and activities.
The learning environment often extends outdoors because Waldorf schools embrace hands-on learning and engagement with nature. Outdoor classes are offered, and students are encouraged to get muddy and play in the rain.
Curriculum and Teaching Methods
Instead of teaching specific skills such as reading, Waldorf encourages students to paint or draw letters until they learn to recognize and write them. The Waldorf approach to reading is substantially different from how it’s taught in mainstream American schools. Students don’t focus on traditional forms of reading until third grade. Instead, they spend time listening to stories and recognizing sounds in the early grades.
Through creative arts, such as knitting and woodworking, students also learn basic arithmetical skills of counting, geometry, and fractions. They learn about science, zoology, and biology by crafting animals and dolls out of pine cones, rocks, and other materials they find outside. In later grades, students also learn through storytelling, hands-on art projects, and textbooks they write and illustrate themselves. Some schools may bring in textbooks for math and foreign languages, though.
Read also: A Comprehensive Look at Waldorf Learning
Pros of Waldorf Education
Waldorf education offers several potential benefits:
Holistic Development
Advocates say its holistic approach - balancing academic subjects with artistic and practical activities - helps foster a love of learning. Activities that deepen and round out one’s understanding of the world in which we live stand side by side with traditional core academic subjects. Cosentino says the fluid and multifaceted nature of Waldorf education helps send students out into the world ready to engage with the community and with further education.
While traditional education might involve teaching toward certain benchmarks, Waldorf education relies on a time-tested curriculum whose graduates have consistently been described as perceptive, thoughtful, extraordinary, skilled, and kind young people. They are proof that academic standards will be met if a student’s whole needs are met.
Emphasis on Creativity and Arts
Many parents who visit a Waldorf school for the first time are attracted by Waldorf’s unique approach: the old-fashioned pace, an abundance of arts and crafts, a dearth of technology, plenty of outdoor education, and an emphasis on hands-on learning. In lieu of whiteboards, you’ll find old-fashioned chalkboards. Students learn about history and mythology through the images and objects they create. If your child is creative, there’s a lot of opportunities to paint, knit, or sew. Music is core to the curriculum; you’ll find musical instruments in nearly every classroom. Budding Thespians can write and act in their own plays.
Creative arts like drawing, painting, language studies, music and drama support the main lesson and give students a variety of avenues to learn the material.
Read also: Navigating the Waldorf Student Portal
Strong Teacher-Student Relationships
Teachers in Waldorf schools typically stay with the same class of students for many years, rather than teaching a specific grade. Cosentino says this design has proven benefits. With a new teacher each year, expectations and personalities take up class time to sort out. As the child changes and new capacities and interests form, the class teacher, having known the student through the years, is quicker to pick up on these and offer support. The Waldorf tradition of “looping” means a teacher stays with the same class for up to eight years. The goal is to promote bonding between students and teachers.
Individualized Learning
Children are treated as individuals and curriculum is tailored to their unique style of learning. Students are discouraged from competing and are free to learn at their own pace. Children learn the meaning of teamwork and community. Working on group art and theater projects helps them learn collaboration at an early age.
Delayed Academics
Waiting until the later grades to teach reading and math promotes long-term achievement. Because brain development occurs at a different pace for each child, the Waldorf approach helps students thrive until their learning skills catch up with their development. What’s more, reading and math is approached differently than in traditional schools. Numbers, math symbols, and letters are introduced in first grade through stories so they are less abstract for children.
Focus on Observation
Observation also takes the place of many standardized tests, though public schools must still comply with state and federal requirements. Rebecca Moskowitz, executive director of advancement for the Association of Waldorf Schools of North America, says observation is a solid foundation for student assessment. Teachers have the ability to accurately assess their students in a holistic and comprehensive manner. These assessments are supported by teacher conferences and class meetings throughout the year.
Cons of Waldorf Education
Despite its many benefits, Waldorf education also has potential drawbacks:
Limited Technology
Unlike most traditional schools, computers and technology are not a part of the everyday learning experience in many elementary and middle school Waldorf classrooms. Moskowitz says that technology is used later on. In high school, computers and digital aids are used in the classroom as teaching tools across disciplines, and computer-specific courses may be taught.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for a technology-intensive classroom that prepares children for a fast-driven world, Waldorf may not be for you. Admissions packets at many Waldorf schools contain strict media policies that parents and students must sign, limiting the child’s access to television, computers, iPods, iPads, video games, and pretty much every electronic device that can distract a young child. At some Waldorf schools, everyday use of electronic media is banned for students until the fifth grade. Beginning in sixth grade and with parental supervision, some Waldorf schools allow students to watch limited amounts of television and movies. Some schools allow sixth graders to carry a cell phone as long as they don’t keep it in their backpacks during school hours, but Internet and video game use is still discouraged. It’s not until high school that most Waldorf schools allow students to have limited use of electronic media, including the Internet and social media.
Critics say lack of access to technology cheats kids. In an increasingly high-tech world, depriving kids of access to and familiarity with technology puts them at a disadvantage and makes little sense.
Delayed Academics
At the same time, a Waldorf school may not be for you if you’re more comfortable with a traditional approach to reading, writing, and arithmetic. It could also not be the right fit if you worry that your child will fall behind if she doesn’t learn the basics in her first few years at school.
Critics say that waiting until the later grades to teach basic skills sets children back. Most do catch up in the later grades, but it’s difficult to assess when children aren’t tested in the early years.
Lack of Standardized Testing
In fact, at many Waldorf schools, students are not introduced to standardized testing until the eighth grade.
Lack of testing gives students a disadvantage. Without standardized testing in the early grades, gauging student progress is difficult. How, critics ask, can you help a student who’s faltering without knowing what he’s learned? What’s more, students are ill-prepared for how to take tests by the time they reach high school and college.
Potential for Copying
Too much copying goes on in classrooms. Instead of using textbooks, students write and draw what they have learned during the day. When children have to write their lessons down each day, it discourages them from actual learning. Journals of daily lessons instead of textbooks: Students hand-write lessons from their teachers each day. These journals contain artwork, math problems, and history lessons all written and drawn by hand.
Limited Competitive Opportunities
Finally, while Waldorf encourages children to roam and play outside, there may not be much chance for organized teams that compete with others. If your child loves competition, she may not get it here.
Cost
Because many Waldorf schools are private, tuition may also be an obstacle for some parents. If it’s a private school, then Waldorf, like other private schools, can be expensive. But some schools do have financial aid. Request a form to be considered for scholarships or other financial aid. Some Waldorf schools are publicly funded charter schools established by a local school district.
Religious Affiliation Concerns
Waldorf schools have a religious affiliation that isn’t fully acknowledged. Waldorf teachings are based on Rudolf Steiner’s philosophy of anthroposophy, which is based on his spiritual beliefs. Throughout his life, Steiner pursued a kind of spiritual research, and wrote about Christianity and its links to Buddhism. Although anthroposophy isn’t taught at Waldorf schools, critics contend Waldorf’s teachings amount to a religion. In some communities where Waldorf philosophies are taught in public charter schools, critics view this as a violation of the separation of church and state.
Making the Decision: Is Waldorf Right for Your Family?
Because a Waldorf education is so different than traditional schooling, it’s worth asking whether a Waldorf school is right not just for your child, but for your entire family. There’s plenty in a Waldorf school that attracts parents - and some aspects that gives them pause.
Parents considering a Waldorf school don’t have to be Luddites themselves - some Silicon Valley executives of top technology companies send their children to Waldorf schools, but you do have to curtail your child’s technology use. When you enroll your child at a Waldorf school, you may have to sign an agreement to limit technology use in your home, at least until your children reach the sixth grade. Although high school students are allowed to use technology, parents are still urged to limit their use of electronic media, such as cell phones and computers.
#
tags: #waldorf #education #pros #and #cons
