Cooperative Education: Bridging the Gap Between Classroom and Career

As students and recent graduates prepare for their careers, cooperative education programs (co-ops) provide an exceptional opportunity to bridge the gap between classroom learning and real-world work experience. A co-op, or cooperative education program, is a structured work experience that blends academic coursework with on-the-job learning. Co-ops allow students to apply their academic knowledge in a professional setting, helping them gain practical skills, build a professional network, and stand out in the job market.

Defining Cooperative Education

Cooperative education is an approach to providing practical, hands-on work with classroom-based training to prepare students for careers in their chosen fields. Unlike short-term internships, co-ops are typically longer, lasting several months to a year. These programs are often facilitated by universities and involve a formal partnership between the university and the employer.

In cooperative education, students alternate between on-campus study and full-time employment, translating theory into practice. The workplace allows them to apply classroom learning to make significant contributions at their organizations.

The History of Cooperative Education

The concept of cooperative education emerged at the beginning of the 20th century. While at Lehigh University, Herman Schneider (1872-1939), an engineer, architect, and educator, concluded that the traditional learning space or classroom was insufficient for technical students. Schneider observed that several more successful Lehigh graduates had worked to earn money before graduation. Gathering data through interviews with employers and graduates, he devised the framework for cooperative education (1901).

However, about that time, Carnegie Technical Schools, now Carnegie Mellon University, opened and thereby minimized the need for Schneider's co-op plan in the region around Lehigh University. In 1903 the University of Cincinnati appointed Schneider to their faculty. In 1905 the UC Board of Trustees allowed Schneider to "try this cooperative idea of education for one year only, for the failure of which they would not be held responsible". The cooperative education program was launched in 1906 and became an immediate success, and the program was kept beyond the one-year allotted. Schneider, beginning from the rank of assistant professor, would rise through the rank of Dean of Engineering (1906-1928) to become interim president (1929-32) of the University of Cincinnati, based largely upon the strength of the co-op program. Throughout his career, he was an advocate for the co-op framework. His thirty years of service to the University of Cincinnati are partly credited for that institution's worldwide fame. In 2006, the University of Cincinnati unveiled a statue of Dean Schneider outside the window of his former office in Baldwin Hall. In 1965, The Cooperative Education and Internship Association (CEIA) created "The Dean Herman Schneider Award" in honor of the contributions made by Dean Schneider to cooperative education. The award is given annually to an outstanding educator from the faculty or administration.

Recognizing the potential of co-op education, Northeastern University began implementing co-op in their engineering program in 1909, becoming the second institution in America to do so. By 1921, Antioch College had adapted co-op practices to their liberal arts curricula, leading many to refer to co-op as the "Antioch Plan." In 1919, the General Motors Institute (GMI) was opened, following this model to train new General Motors hires. The Drexel University four-year co-op program launched in the College of Engineering in 1919, with the participation of just three academic majors. This initiative stemmed from the belief of the university founder, Anthony J. Drexel, that Drexel University should prepare its students for successful careers through an education that balanced classroom theory with real-world practice. In 1925, the five-year co-op program took hold in the chemical engineering department, forming the foundation of Drexel's cooperative education program. In 1922, Northeastern University emphasized its commitment to co-op by extending it to the College of Business Administration. As new colleges opened at Northeastern, such as the College of Liberal Arts (1935) and the College of Education (1953), they became co-op schools as well. In 1926, Dean Schneider invited those interested in forming an Association of Co-operative Colleges (ACC) to the University of Cincinnati for the first convention. The idea took hold and was followed by three more annual conventions.

In 1957, the first Canadian cooperative education program began at the University of Waterloo with an inaugural class of 75. Initially viewed skeptically, this program quickly became a model for other co-op programs across Canada. These programs were based on both the sandwich education model popularized in Britain and the new American co-op programs. Canadian co-op programs generally follow a four-month school system interspersed with four-month work terms.

In 1961, the Ford and Edison Foundations commissioned a study of cooperative education, published as Work-study college programs; appraisal and report of the study of cooperative education, (James Warner Wilson and Edward H Lyons, New York: Harper). This study led to the formation of the National Commission for Cooperative Education (NCCE). NCCE remains today to promote and lobby for cooperative education in the United States. Within Canada, the need for connections between co-op programs became clear by 1973. The Canadian Association for Co-operative Education (CAFCE) began with 29 educators from 15 institutions. In its initial form, it did not include any employers or industry representatives. The institutions felt that they should decide on an integrative plan for co-op education prior to admitting employers as members.

By 1962, about 150 academic institutions used co-op education, in one form or another. Many were outside of engineering. The need for professional support of non-engineering programs became obvious, and the membership of ASEE, in 1963, began the Cooperative Education Association. To reflect its membership more accurately, it was eventually renamed the Cooperative Education and Internship Association.

Much of those early efforts of NCCE focused on lobbying and promoting cooperative education. In 1965, the federal Higher Education Act provided support specifically for cooperative education. Funding continued from the federal government through 1992 when Congress ended its support of cooperative education. In Canada, regulation of cooperative education programs is overseen by CAFCE. Programs can apply for accreditation after the first class of co-op students has graduated.

In 1979, educators from Australia, Britain, Canada, and the United States (Northeastern's President, Kenneth Ryder), met to discuss work-related programs in their respective countries. In 1981 and 1982, this group, headed by President Ryder, convened an international conference on cooperative education. In 1983, several college and university presidents, educational specialists, and employers from around the world (including Australia, Canada, Hong Kong, the Netherlands, the Philippines, the United States, and the United Kingdom) formed the World Council and Assembly on Cooperative Education to foster cooperative education worldwide. In 1991, it renamed itself the World Association for Cooperative Education (WACE).

Cooperative education is common in most Australian high schools and has been integrated into many university courses as a part of making up final grades. Australian institutions often refer to cooperative education as Work Placement, VET, or Prac. All of these involve students going into their chosen field and joining that field for a set number of weeks in unpaid work. This unpaid work goes towards credits for graduation in both schools and universities Australia-wide. The Australian government has been funding this program due to the success of highly regarded applicants who have come from doing work placements.

Cooperative Education in Germany

Duality is key in the German model: Two learning facilities must be provided: academic studies and vocational training. A cooperative study program is a combination of academic study at a university or vocational college and vocational education. The programs typically lead to a bachelor's degree, but there are also a few Master's programs. Vocational training focuses on practical education.

The first cooperative education programs, in terms of studies with integrated practical phases, started in 1970. The next step was the foundation of a new tertiary education institution, a vocational university. That enabled the establishment of a cooperative study program, originally founded in Baden-Württemberg. More people had been graduating from high school with the highest school certificate: "Abitur". This had led to an increase in the number of students attending university and a decrease in the number of trainees and apprentices in vocational training. On one hand, companies were apprehensive about a lack of skilled workers.

In 1996, the science council recommended an increased focus on cooperative education. Baden-Württemberg's vocational universities were merged as DHBW, cooperative state university Baden-Württemberg in 2009. Other vocational universities were also approved as state universities. From 2004 to 2014, the number of students has increased from 40,982 to 100,739. There were 47,458 companies providing cooperative study programs in 2016, compared to 18,168 in 2004. Small, medium, and large companies have established programs in different departments. There are different dual curriculum programs. The number of courses grew from 512 in 2014 to 1,592 in 2016.

Read also: ESL Classroom Activities

There is a contract between the three participating parties (employee, employer, and university of cooperative education) over the time of the study. Mostly, the employer provides payment which is slightly above the payment for a vocational training. Some companies also pay student fees. Since most universities are public in Germany, there are no student fees, just dues, which are around $400 per semester. There are usually agreements including a guaranteed employment after the program. Therefore, some contracts include terms where students commit to stay with the company for at least two years after the program. Even without guaranteed employment, chances of getting a job are high anyway. Around 72% of students stay with the sponsoring company after studies for at least two to five years. A common issue is that many students want to do their masters afterwards.

Cooperative Education in Canada

Since 1973, Canada has had a national body representing cooperative education and work integrated learning. This national body used to be called CAFCE (Canadian Association for Co-op Education) and was renamed CEWIL Canada (Cooperative Education and Work Integrated Learning Canada) in 2017. This organization has representatives from Canadian post-secondary institutions and employers who work together to develop resources to promote the highest quality of post-secondary work-integrated learning programs.

CEWIL Canada works to establish national standards for WIL programs. The organization also allows for delivery of training opportunities and best practice sharing. CEWIL maintains a national database on WIL with data from more than fifty post-secondary member institutions. CEWIL reports that over 75,000 students are participating in co-operative education programs across the country.

Work Integrated Learning (WIL) is the commonly accepted term for a wide range of experiential learning opportunities in Canada. Work Integrated Learning (WIL) is considered to be inclusive of educational programs that incorporate a workplace-based component that has connections to the classroom through various learning goals designated in the students' program or curriculum. It is widely accepted that WIL opportunities have value and produce benefit for students and employers, including employment readiness (such as gaining job-related skills and knowing what kind of job opportunity a student would want to have after graduation). Students participating in WIL can experience new environments, tasks, colleagues for typically a shorter period of time. Work Integrated Learning includes Cooperative Education which is typically a paid work experience of three, four, eight, twelve or sixteen months. When surveyed by Miriam Kramer in a study in 2011, 92% of students Agreed or Strongly Agreed that their co-op work term had a positive impact on critical & analytical thinking, problem solving and decision-making skills.

In Canada, another grouping of industry and education professionals came together to create The Business Higher Education Roundtable (BHER). The BHER was established by the Business Council of Canada in 2015 and works on two goals: Helping young Canadians transition from higher education to workplaces through collaborative partnerships and post-secondary institutions.

Models of Cooperative Education

From its beginnings in Cincinnati in 1906, cooperative education has evolved into a program offered at the secondary and post-secondary levels in two predominant models. In one model, students alternate a semester of academic coursework with an equal amount of time working, repeating this cycle several times until graduation. The parallel method splits the day between school and work, typically structured to accommodate the student's class schedule. Thus, like school-to-work (STW), the co-op model includes school-based and work-based learning and "connecting activities" such as seminars and teacher-coordinator work site visits.

Other models, such as the sandwich model and the American-style semester model, instead have students work a 40-hour work week for a set amount of time, typically between 12 weeks and six months. After this period is over, students return to the classroom for an academic semester after which they may have another work term. This cycle often repeats multiple times, adding a year or more to the students' university career.

Benefits of Cooperative Education

Co-ops play a vital role in preparing students for the workforce. They offer hands-on learning experiences in a real-world environment, helping students develop a deeper understanding of their field of study. By participating in a co-op, students can explore different career paths, build professional connections, and apply theoretical knowledge to practical challenges.

Co-ops offer numerous advantages for students looking to kick-start their careers, including:

Hands-on Experience: Co-ops provide students with hands-on experience directly related to their academic field, allowing them to develop industry-specific skills and knowledge.
Competitive Edge: Students with co-op experience often have a competitive edge in the job market. The University of Cincinnati reports that 88% of its co-op students secure full-time employment or continue their education after graduation, demonstrating the value of co-op experience in career development.
Earning Potential: Many co-ops are paid positions, providing students with an opportunity to earn an income while still in school. For example, students at Drexel University earn a median six-month co-op salary of over $19,000, which helps offset the cost of education and living expenses.
Career Advancement: One of the most significant benefits of a co-op is its impact on career advancement. Northeastern University, which is known for its extensive co-op program, reports that 95% of its graduates are employed or enrolled in graduate school within nine months of graduation. In many cases, co-op participants receive full-time job offers from the companies where they completed their co-op.
Skill Development: Co-ops provide opportunities to develop industry-specific skills, such as technical abilities, project management, and communication. Students also build meaningful relationships with colleagues, mentors, and hiring managers. These connections can lead to job offers and references in the future.
Motivation, career clarity, enhanced employability, and vocational maturity
Offset higher education costs, enabling more people to afford college.
Access to a range of practical learning applications that enhance their critical thinking, decision-making, interpersonal and problem-solving skills.

Co-op's proponents identify benefits for employers (labor force flexibility, recruitment/retention of trained workers, and input into curricula) as well as educational institutions and society.

Benefits for Employers

A consistent flow of prepared and well-educated candidates.
Leverage co-op work as a training tool for future employment.
Sponsoring institutions receive feedback to create or improve their programs.

Finding and Applying for Co-ops

Finding the right co-op requires strategic planning and research. Many universities have dedicated career services offices that connect students with co-op opportunities.

Applying for a co-op requires preparation and persistence. It's important to practice answering questions about how you’ve balanced academic and professional responsibilities. For international students, it’s crucial to ensure that your academic credentials are properly evaluated.

Co-ops vs. Internships

Co-ops, internships, and part-time jobs all provide work experience, but they differ in structure and purpose. Co-ops are generally longer (six months to a year) and are often linked to academic credit, while internships are shorter and may or may not be tied to coursework. Co-ops also offer more intensive learning opportunities, giving students a deeper view of their chosen profession. Also, internships are often low- or no-pay positions. Their primary benefit is allowing students to gain some industry experience that may help them land an entry-level role in the future. Conversely, cooperative education positions are generally higher-paying. Other job factors that vary between the two include working hours and simultaneous coursework.

Examples of Universities with Strong Co-op Programs

Several universities are renowned for their cooperative education programs. These institutions have a long history of connecting students with meaningful work experiences and preparing them for successful careers.

University of Cincinnati: The first college in the US to offer cooperative education, the University of Cincinnati offers several different co-op models for students with various learning styles. Students can participate in a co-op job part-time and still take classes while working.
Northeastern University: Northeastern University boasts an extensive and highly successful co-op program, offering work experience in the US and in countries like New Zealand, Bali and Peru. Before beginning work, Northeastern students take a required co-op prep course. At the conclusion of each co-op semester, students complete a reflection on their work experience.
Drexel University: Drexel University’s well-known co-op program began in 1919 and is one of the oldest in the country. Students have several options for co-op education at Drexel, including a plan that lets them complete two different co-op jobs and still graduate in four years.
Cornell University: Cornell’s Engineering Co-op Education Experience is available to undergraduates at Cornell who have declared an Engineering major and completed at least two semesters of coursework. Students take only one semester off to work full-time, and complete assignments related to the job to submit to their advisors.

The Role of Education Cooperatives

Education cooperatives exist in a variety of forms, from early childhood education to undergraduate programs. Preschools, for example, can operate as a co-op in which the parent-members determine policies and serve on committees.

At the college level, cooperative education has a different meaning. Many universities offer co-op education programs, which combine classroom learning with professional employment experience. Students gain academic credit for compensated job experience directly related to their majors. Education cooperatives help prepare students for their future careers through practical, professional development.

These organizations are groups of parents who oversee and provide their children’s education at home. Each operates differently based on their schedules and purposes, though some follow the university model. Cooperative education options in private schools include those similar to homeschooling. Parents or school leadership may organize programs by working with community members. Numerous public secondary and post-secondary schools also offer cooperative education programs. These options connect work experience and classroom-based learning for students across multiple disciplines.

tags: #cooperative #education #definition #and #examples