Accessibility in Higher Education: Challenges and Solutions

The pursuit of higher education should be an equitable opportunity for all, yet significant barriers persist for students with disabilities (SWDs) and other disadvantaged groups. This article explores the challenges to accessibility in higher education and proposes potential solutions, drawing on research, real-world examples, and evolving perspectives on inclusivity.

The Imperative of Accessibility

Prioritizing accessibility within academic programming and educational technology (edtech) is imperative for meeting student needs now and into the future. Education today must be accessible to students seeking in-person, online, and hybrid experiences - and not only in a linear fashion but also on an as-needed basis. Institutions must identify and adopt practices in the classroom as well as within technology that serve all students across the evolving educational landscape.

Understanding Disadvantaged Students

Not every student has the same opportunity to access and benefit from higher education. Many factors can create barriers and inequalities for students and impact their likelihood of success. As a result, advancing access and equity for these students in higher education is critical. Underrepresented or disadvantaged students are those who face barriers or challenges in accessing and succeeding in education due to factors such as race, ethnicity, gender, disability, socioeconomic status, language, or geographic location.

Some examples of underrepresented students are:

Students of color, who may experience discrimination, stereotyping, lack of culturally inclusive environments and additional socioeconomic barriers to success.
Female students in STEM fields, who may encounter gender bias, harassment, a lack of female role models and professional development opportunities.
Students with disabilities, who may have difficulty finding adequate accommodations, support services, or inclusive learning environments.
Low-income students, who may struggle with financial constraints, food insecurity, or limited access to technology and other resources.
First-generation students, who may struggle in their preparedness for university, lack a feeling of belonging and adequate support systems.
English language learners, who may face language barriers, academic gaps, or low levels of parental involvement.
Rural students, who may have limited exposure to diverse perspectives, opportunities, or accommodation and transport.

Challenges in Advancing Access and Equity

Advancing access and equity is an important goal for higher education, but it also poses significant challenges. Some of the challenges in advancing access and equity in higher education include:

The persistent gaps in academic achievement and attainment among underrepresented student groups.
The lack of adequate financial support and resources for students who face barriers to access and success, such as tuition fees, living expenses, transportation, childcare, or health care.
The need for more diverse and inclusive curricula, pedagogy, faculty, staff, and leadership that reflect and respect the diversity of students and society.
The impact of social and cultural factors on students’ sense of belonging, engagement, and identity in higher education, such as stereotypes, discrimination, microaggressions, or campus climate.

Barriers Faced by Students with Disabilities

While there has been a growing awareness of the importance of accessibility in education, universities still fall short to provide a fully inclusive and supportive learning environment for students with disabilities. The challenges disabled students face within the higher education system can significantly impact their ability to thrive. Numerous studies suggest that graduation rates among SWDs are lower than those of their counterparts without disabilities, and research further shows that SWDs report lower rates of college adjustment. As a result, SWDs tend to experience a more stressful daily life and may suffer from fewer opportunities compared to their peers without disabilities.

Physical and Technological Barriers

Common barriers include outdated infrastructure, inaccessible buildings and learning materials, lack of assistive technologies, and so on. Inaccessible infrastructure and built environment presents significant challenges. Students with disabilities experience challenges in daily activities like daily commuting to and from school, particularly in urban regions where traffic jams, collisions and transit issues are prevalent. Schools in poor nations lack accessibility features like ramps and special restrooms for pupils with disabilities. Hewett et al. pinpointed the campus with poor lighting and pathways. Due to mistakes in flooring designs, such as moisture on the floor during the monsoon and slightly different tile colours that increase the risk of accidents, students with disabilities confront seasonal barriers.

Attitudinal and Social Barriers

In addition to physical or technological barriers, students with disabilities face the higher education community’s lack of awareness and understanding of disabilities. A 2015 study by Barbara Hong indicated that the most frequent barrier faced by students with disabilities lies in how they are perceived by faculty once they reveal their need for accommodations. Socially, SWDs continue to experience alienation from peers, which negatively affects their self-esteem and prevents them from feeling the sense of belonging that every student deserves. As a result, SWDs are more likely to worry about vital daily interactions, which can negatively affect their mental health. Students with disabilities encounter discrimination from instructors, institutions and other students without disabilities. Additionally, peers bully and socially reject handicapped pupils and they encounter discrimination and stereotypes because of their impairment. One of the main obstacles to enrolling in some courses was negative stereotyping based on the impairment classification.

Systemic and Resource-Related Barriers

Students with disabilities often face significant challenges due to the lack of necessary resources. Libraries are often insufficiently stocked with materials to support these students, and they are frequently denied access to lecture notes. Another problem is a lack of skilled personnel. The cost of assistive technology is a grievance voiced by educational institutions. For instance, when there were no technical supports available to impaired students or when certain equipment were malfunctioning, their involvement in class activities decreased. In order to access educational materials and resources, students with disabilities need assistive technology such as screen readers. Concerns with the privacy and security of personal information are raised by the need for others to provide access to educational materials and services. Too often, universities are unable to provide any form of accommodation to disabled students unless they have a formal medical diagnosis. Instead, universities should provide a team of well-prepared counselors to intermediate the dialogue between students and administration and encourage disabled students to speak up about their needs. Collaboration with disabled students is essential in ensuring their needs are met.

Data Scarcity and Understanding

General data regarding disability in higher education is still lacking, but universities can run periodic surveys and town halls among their students to better know their needs. Limited data on the number of SWDs in higher education. Several factors contribute to this data scarcity. Some students choose not to disclose their disability out of fear of discrimination. Moreover, some underdeveloped or developing countries still have no wealthy reservoir of relevant data or no reliable means of data collection. Finally, in cases where data is actually available, data retrieval may be difficult because of privacy protections. Because of the data deficit, not all SWDs’ challenges and concerns in the higher education system are fully represented.

Academic Barriers

At the university level, inaccessibility for SWDs may arise in different contexts. The effects continue at the academic level, where SWDs can show poor performance and intellectual distress when not well supported. Students with disabilities in higher education report that there are inflexible curricula, students have communication issues, privacy issues, difficulties with self-disclosure of their disability and mental and academic difficulties.

Strategies to Support Disadvantaged Students

To support disadvantaged students in accessing and succeeding in higher education, institutions need well-defined policies, streamlined strategies, effective incentives and appropriate support services and resource allocation. To address these concerns in earnest, schools must find inclusive solutions and devise innovative assistive technologies that will help SWDs pursue their degrees with fewer challenges and greater motivation.

Some of the most effective strategies to advance access and equity in higher education include:

1. Recruitment, Enrollment and Opportunity

Work to support disadvantaged students should begin before they set foot on your campus or enroll at your institution. The initial work should begin in creating courses and modules that will suit and appeal to underrepresented groups, to attract them to higher education. Secondly, institutions should be actively recruiting students from underrepresented groups, creating pathways between local high schools or community colleges.

In addition, educators should enhance the readiness of potential students through academic preparation such as bridging programs and work to remove financial and access barriers through lower tuition fees for underrepresented groups, greater scholarship opportunities and affordable accommodation options.

Read also: Preserving Baby Mustard

2. Comprehensive Student Support Systems

As well as financial support and academic preparedness, higher education institutions need robust student support systems to provide a wide range of assistance for the diverse challenges these students face. Disadvantaged students often have a greater need for mental health services, financial aid and budgetary advice, career guidance and academic advising, than other student groups.

It is important to give students access to these resources as early as possible in their education journey and ensure they are aware of the support available to them. In addition, it is crucial education institutions make their support services as effective as possible for the students who need them most.

In many cases, disadvantaged students have lower satisfaction and effectiveness rates for student services than their more advantaged peers. As a result, institutions need to do more to improve this.

3. Digital Technologies to Support Student Success

Digital technology is another key tool in advancing access and equity in education. Data analytics can help institutions evaluate their policies and strategies, understand student’s needs, provide more personalized, effective support and improve interventions for disadvantaged students.

Successful data analytics systems are often supported by an early warning system that will prompt interventions and timely outreach from staff. These systems can also greatly contribute to the success of academic advising efforts and other support services. With more insights into student progression, advisors can provide more effective, targeted support. In addition, having student data centrally stored in one system across different support services, can eliminate the ineffectiveness, inefficiency and time delay often associated with data silos.

Providing Comprehensive Disability Services

Providing comprehensive disability services on campus by specialized counselors is essential in ensuring disabled students receive the necessary support. This training should focus on increasing awareness and understanding of various disabilities, eliminating misconceptions, and promoting empathy and inclusivity. Moreover, counseling and mental health support should address the unique emotional and psychological challenges faced by disabled students.

Embracing Universal Design for Learning (UDL)

Universal design has many different names, such as universal design in instruction or learning, and is based on tenants of universal design in physical access. UD intends to create access to as many students as possible by limiting barriers throughout the learning process. Research expands the understanding of UD in higher education by exploring faculty attitudes. For the most part, all faculty in the study report favorable attitudes toward UD. However, 42% of faculty indicate they do not fully understand UD, and 16% report that they do not consider UD in their lessons.

Leveraging Technology and AI for Accessibility

Technology is also increasingly looked to as a way to address various access barriers. However, emerging technology is accompanied by its own unique accessibility challenges. Technology can also be extremely advantageous for creating more accessible campus experiences. For example, assistive technology can help address print-related disabilities such as enlarging text, having text read aloud, or through dictation. As AI becomes increasingly embedded into educational settings and practices, it offers both opportunities and challenges. Our goal is to shift the conversation around AI in higher education beyond topics like academic integrity or the student experience, and instead encourage a focus on how AI can promote accessibility and inclusion.

Policy Changes and In-Class Support

Reasonable policy changes: One ADA center was contacted by a disability services office at a community college that had received a request related to a culinary class being taken by a student with a disability. The student provided documentation indicating that due to their seizure condition they were not able to use knives or operate equipment required in the course. The College administration wanted the student to take an incomplete for course and submit an application for tuition reimbursement, which included a potentially lengthy administrative process. The technical assistant discussed the obligation for reasonable modification of policy and procedure and how the student should be allowed to withdraw from the course and receive tuition reimbursement without having to go through the administrative process of petitioning for it.

Providing in class supports: Another ADA center was contacted after a college student with a learning disability was denied access to copies of class lecture and slideshow notes. The professor argued that such items were intellectual property and had a legal right not to share. The Technical Assistant provided state level information regarding core services that specifically addressed instructor-produced materials as well as rights and responsibilities under the ADA and Section 504 to the student, disability services office, and the professor.

Examples of Institutional Initiatives

Despite the challenges that still exist, a number of institutions worldwide have made relentless efforts to revolutionize education so that it is more inclusive.

American University of Beirut (AUB): At AUB, with the support of OSB’s deans, faculty, and staff as well as technological advancements across the university, Farah was able to equip himself with a fully accessible office and classroom dedicated to giving his lectures. For class presentations, he uses a large font on his slides and a special projector that both accommodates the larger font and projects images lower than usual, in line with Farah’s field of vision. The university also has an Accessible Education Office, which Farah helped inaugurate. AUB also started the Accessibility for a Bolder Learning Experience (ABLE) initiative, which helps bring awareness to accessibility issues in higher education.
HEC Paris: The business school employs “medical referents,” staff who work closely with SWDs to understand critical issues and provide support, as well as with the administrative offices focused on serving students.
University of Warwick: The university’s main library has numerous rooms with different options for seating (bean bags, cushions, rocking chairs, etc.), lighting, music, and other facilities that are sensory accessible.
University of Huddersfield: The university offers widespread availability of recorded class lectures as well as an assistive technology support service, HudStudy.
Wheely Wheel: An important startup on the rise that is promoting accessibility in innovative ways is Wheely Wheel, which aims to accelerate the momentum toward an inclusive world. Wheely Wheel presents an accessibility solution that is unique in the Middle East region. It offers a map that ranks a variety of places (universities, restaurants, hotels, supermarkets, etc.) based on their accessibility features. The map will cater to a number of disability types. Wheely Wheel plans to include university campuses in the ranking process, which will give students detailed information about accessibility features available at universities.

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)

Passed in 1990, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a landmark civil rights law that addresses discrimination based on disability. The ADA represents bipartisan support for disability inclusion in multiple aspects of public life by allowing individuals with disabilities to challenge discrimination in the realms of employment, public services, and places of public use. Through the ADA disability is a recognized source of discrimination, similar to “race, color, religion, sex, or national origin” within the Civil Rights Act of 1964. With the ADA in effect for almost three decades, there is a growing number of students with disabilities going to college. Institutions of higher education are responsible for fulfilling the social and legal promise of disability rights laws.

Transitioning from High School to College

Transitioning from high school to college can be a barrier for students with disabilities. As more students with disabilities access higher education, there is a need for stronger and more intentional transition programming between high school and postsecondary institutions. Students with disabilities have expressed significantly lower expectations of graduating from 4-year institutions compared to students without disabilities. Most transition programs and policies focus almost exclusively on preparing students with disabilities for employment. Another key barrier identified in the research is related to connecting students to appropriate campus resources.

The Role of Disability Services

Universities have developed disability service offices to fulfill both legal and ethical obligations of supporting students with disabilities through offering protection from discrimination and providing accommodations as part of compliance with related laws. Students are referred to disability services through a variety of ways. One study looked at how students with psychiatric disabilities become connected to university disability services.

While disability services are different across various campus settings, there are essential services that all disability services offices can and should provide. The Association on Higher Education and Disability (AHEAD) details standards of the primary purposes of disability services as raising awareness, disseminating information, counseling and advocacy, fostering collaboration across campus, providing academic adjustments and instructional interventions, developing and evaluating programs, and offering training and professional development opportunities. Recommendations for disability services to move beyond compliance with the law to building an inclusive environment, include: 1) learning about universal design, 2) including input from students receiving services, 3) increasing and supporting collaborations across campus, 4) and reviewing and/or updating policies to reflect the social model of disability

tags: #accessibility #in #higher #education #challenges #and