Enhancing Education: Exploring the Effectiveness of Social and Emotional Learning Programs
There is a growing consensus among educators, parents, and policymakers that education should encompass the development of essential social and emotional capacities, enabling children to successfully navigate the complexities of the world. To cultivate these competencies, many schools are implementing social and emotional learning (SEL) programs. These programs aim to nurture the "whole child" by fostering abilities such as developing healthy relationships, treating others with respect, enhancing problem-solving skills, and promoting success in education and the workforce.
The Rise of SEL and Its Framework
In 2017, the National Commission on Social, Emotional, and Academic Development formed a council of scientists to examine evidence regarding SEL across various disciplines. The council concluded that social and emotional competencies are crucial for learning, positive development, and success in various aspects of life. Over the past two decades, research has demonstrated the impact of SEL on children's well-being, behavior, and academic outcomes.
Many states have now established learning standards for SEL, drawing upon different frameworks. A prominent framework is the CASEL wheel, developed by the Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL). This framework organizes five competence clusters: self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, relationship skills, and responsible decision-making.
Meta-Analyses: A Comprehensive Overview of SEL Program Effectiveness
A recent report reviewed findings from 12 meta-analyses of school-based SEL programs, revealing a consistent and reliable effect of evidence-based SEL programs on students' social, emotional, behavioral, and academic outcomes in PreK-12th grade. These outcomes include the development of social and emotional skills, improved academic engagement and performance, growth of positive social behaviors, and lower rates of behavior problems and psychological distress.
These meta-analyses included programs across all grade levels (PreK-12), with some focusing on preschool children or secondary school students. Effect size was used to measure the impact of SEL programming on various outcomes. The findings, based on hundreds of studies spanning six continents, indicate that tested, evidence-based SEL programs have a consistent, reliable effect on students’ social, emotional, behavioral, and academic outcomes at all grade levels (PreK-12th grade) and across gender, ethnicity and race, income, and other demographic variables. The effect sizes are classified as medium to large, indicating the SEL programs studied were substantially beneficial to children.
Read also: Scholarships for Cybersecurity Professionals
Key Findings from Recent Studies
A study led by Christina Cipriano and Michael Strambler analyzed 424 experimental studies of SEL, reflecting over 50 countries and more than 250 discrete SEL programs from the past decade. The study confirmed that students who participated in SEL programs demonstrated increased academic achievement and school functioning, including improved attendance and engagement in learning. They also showed improved social and emotional skills, attitudes, and behaviors, such as self-efficacy, self-esteem, mindset, perseverance, and optimism, among others. Furthermore, students reported less anxiety, stress, depression, and suicidal thoughts and felt more connected and included with better relationships with peers and teachers.
The study also found that the positive effects of SEL programs on student social and emotional skills continue six months or more after a program ends. Specific features of SEL programs, such as high-quality, sequenced, active, focused, and explicit (SAFE) programs delivered by teachers, have the strongest positive effects on students.
This meta-analysis was the first of its kind to systematically examine several previously unexamined domains of SEL, resulting in new findings that influence future research, practice, and policy specific to school safety and civic behaviors. The largest effect of SEL programs was on students' increased perceptions of safety and inclusion at school. SEL programs also demonstrated positive effects in both prosocial behaviors and civic behaviors and attitudes.
Integrating SEL into Academic Instruction
A meta-analysis of 40 empirical studies on SEL programs assessed their academic impact on students. The results revealed that students who participated in universal SEL programs showed a statistically significant improvement-a 4.2 percentile-point increase-in overall academic achievement compared to a control group. The study’s findings “highlight the close interconnection among the domains of social, emotional, and cognitive learning in child and adolescent development."
For educational policymakers, the study provides “rigorous scientific evidence that participation in SEL programs not only strengthens social and emotional skills but also contributes to meaningful academic gains, showing that success in school is closely tied to well-being and interpersonal growth."
Read also: Choosing a Social Science Major
The Importance of Implementation and Support
Although many schools have adopted SEL programs, they are not always well implemented. Effective delivery requires substantial training and support for teachers, including initial training, ongoing coaching and mentoring, and technical support. Supporting teachers’ own social and emotional competence through training that includes emotional awareness, stress management, and mindfulness has also shown great promise in reducing teacher stress and improving classroom instruction.
A principal’s active support for implementation of SEL programming is essential. Principals themselves must be knowledgeable about evidence-based SEL models and how to effectively provide support to teachers. SEL is more effective and sustained in schools in which SEL and whole child development are integrated and reinforced throughout the entirety of the school environment.
SEL Beyond the Classroom: Partnerships and Community Involvement
Families and educators recognize that SEL extends beyond the classroom and is reinforced in every setting and interaction young people experience. Schools can work with afterschool programs to build students’ social-emotional skills throughout the day.
An initiative study found that committed leadership, guidance from SEL committees, time for SEL in schedules, training for adults, short SEL rituals, trusting relationships, formal SEL resources, and a sense of ownership helped schools and afterschool programs work together on SEL. The research team also has recommendations for afterschool and summer programs looking to add SEL, including phasing in instruction, offering staff training, sharing information with families, and tracking progress toward SEL goals.
Choosing the Right SEL Program
Schools and afterschool providers can choose the right type of SEL program by consulting guides that offer detailed information on evidence-based programs for different age groups. These guides include worksheets to help users choose a program.
Read also: Landing a Social Media Internship
tags: #social #and #emotional #learning #programs #effectiveness
