Situated Learning Theory: Bridging the Gap Between Theory and Practice
There’s only so much we gain from reading books and watching videos. After all, we don’t learn to swim, cook, or ride a bike this way. Situated Learning Theory emphasizes the importance of context in the learning process. It posits that learners acquire knowledge and skills best when engaged in authentic activities within real-world settings. In essence, this is situated learning - where theory meets practice, and real understanding begins.
Introduction: The Essence of Situated Learning
Situated learning is an instructional approach developed by Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger in the early 1990s and follows the work of Dewey, Vygotsky, and others who claim that students are more inclined to learn by actively participating in the learning experience. Situated learning essentially is a matter of creating meaning from the real activities of daily living where learning occurs relative to the teaching environment. At a time when cognitive and behavioral theories dominated the landscape of learning theories, Lave and Wenger's situated learning theory (SLT) opened new territory by illuminating social and cultural learning processes.
Core Principles of Situated Learning
Situated learning is based on ideas from many fields, such as psychology, sociology, cognitive science, and anthropology. Situated learning suggests that learning takes place through the relationships between people and connecting prior knowledge with authentic, informal, and often unintended contextual learning. In this situation, a student’s role changes from being a beginner to an expert as they become more active and immersed in the social community where learning often is “unintentional rather than deliberate”. Therefore, the social community matures and learns through collaboration and “sharing of purposeful, patterned activity”.
Learning in Context
Without context, it’s difficult to grasp how or even why the knowledge should be applied. Placing a learner in a real-world situation or experience gives meaningful context to what they are learning.
Active Participation
Students are more inclined to learn by actively participating in the learning experience. These examples illustrate that students are actively involved in addressing real world problems. As the practice implies, the student is “situated” in the learning experience and knowledge acquisition becomes a part of the learning activity, its context, and the “culture in which it is developed and used”. Students form or “construct” their own knowledge from experiences they bring to the learning situation; the success of situated learning experiences relies on social interaction and kinesthetic activity.
Read also: Understanding PLCs
Social Interaction
Social interactions play a significant role in the learning process. Situated learning involves students in cooperative activities where they are challenged to use their critical thinking and kinesthetic abilities. These activities should be applicable and transferable to students’ homes, communities, and workplaces.
Knowledge Construction
Traditional learning occurs from abstract, out of context experiences such as lectures and books. Situated learning, on the other hand, suggests that learning takes place through the relationships between people and connecting prior knowledge with authentic, informal, and often unintended contextual learning.
Legitimate Peripheral Participation
Learning viewed as situated activity has as its central defining characteristic a process that we call legitimate peripheral participation. By this we mean to draw attention to the point that learners inevitably participate in communities of practitioners and that the mastery of knowledge requires newcomers to move toward full participation in the sociocultural practices of a community. ‘Legitimate peripheral participation’ provides a way to speak about the relations between newcomers and old timers, and about activities, identities, artifacts and communities of knowledge and practice. It concerns the process by which newcomers become part of a community of practice. A person’s intentions to learn are engaged and the meaning of learning is configured through the process of becoming a full participant in a sociocultural practice.
Contrasting Situated Learning with Traditional Methods
Situational cognition is vastly different from traditional learning. First of all, traditional lessons use abstract experiences, such as textbooks and lectures, to teach ideas. Situated learning occurs in the context of the experience. Secondly, traditional lessons focus only on the relationship between the student and the instructor. Situational learning places great emphasis on relationships and interactions with others in order to build understanding. Students learn by making connections to their prior knowledge. And third, situational learning works to develop the role of the individual within the greater community. As a student gains more knowledge in one area, they are able to collaborate with others and play a more prominent role in the community. They are able to share their understanding in turn and the cycle begins again.
Examples of Situated Learning
Let’s go back to our cooking example. If you watch a video about how to make a beef wellington, do you really know and understand how to do it? You may gain some basic understanding of what you need to do, but it’s not the same as actually making the beef wellington yourself.
Read also: Learning Resources Near You
Medical Training
For example, the theory of diagnosing a patient is, on paper, very straightforward. Through situated learning, students get to experience real-world scenarios in a safe environment. Rather than being let loose into the world alone, learners are closely supervised and observed to ensure they are applying their knowledge correctly.
Driving Lessons
Driving lessons are a good example of this. The act of driving on the road is a situated learning experience. However, you don’t just jump into a car and hit the gas. First, you must learn the theory.
Internships
Let’s take an internship in a busy office, for example. The intern must observe and learn from ongoing operations without interfering with the daily tasks of the office staff. This approach still provides the required hands-on experience, however, the experts can continue performing their usual duties while still providing guidance when needed. Your job at this point falls into the role of coach. As the learner advances their skills and grows in confidence, you reduce your support accordingly.
Field Trips
Field trips, where students actively participate in an unfamiliar environment offer educational and practical experiences. Similarly, students get completely immersed during music or sports practice sessions that imitate real-life events, ie. orchestras, studios, competitive matches, etc. In the same context, how about creating a “Corporate Sales Office” as your classroom? Learners are Sales Managers with independent targets, client lists, etc. Use these as classrooms in which students are put to work in situations that replicate real-life, and illustrate scenarios where students are engaged in finding solutions to real problems. As the theory suggests, the student is “situated” in the learning process, and knowledge acquisition becomes a part of the learning activity.
Role-Playing and Simulations
Simulations and scenarios that mirror real life also provide a risk-free environment where learners can practice their skills without fear of making harmful mistakes. Facilitate role-playing: Role-playing activities mimic real-world tasks and scenarios, allowing learners to practice controlled environments without fear of failure. Use lifelike scenarios: Realistic and interactive storytelling allows students to explore different perspectives and outcomes. By using “branching,” the outcome of the scenario is determined by the learner’s choices. For instance, tools like Simul8 provide virtual scenarios that mirror real-world challenges. And, software like Twine lets you create lifelike scenarios where learners make decisions and experience consequences.
Read also: Learning Civil Procedure
The Role of Experts and Mentors
Rather than being let loose into the world alone, learners are closely supervised and observed to ensure they are applying their knowledge correctly. Experts should also track the learner’s progress and assess their abilities. In most cases, assessment is going to involve some kind of practical demonstration of the learner’s abilities.
Coaching and Scaffolding
This is the stage that requires a lot of investigation and research because you must ensure that the contexts are fully relevant to the learning experience. Once you have selected the appropriate contexts, you must determine how learners can operate within them while still permitting the experts to work within the same situation. As the learner advances their skills and grows in confidence, you reduce your support accordingly. Provide a scaffold for new learners, knowing the type and intensity of guidance necessary to help learners master the situations. Select situations that will engage the learners in complex, realistic, problem-centered activities…
Assessment Techniques
Expert observation: Mentors or experts observe learners as they perform tasks in real or simulated settings. Peer assessment: Learners provide feedback on each other’s work, discuss problem-solving strategies, and reflect on group tasks.
Challenges and Considerations
Let’s also keep in mind that situated learning is often resource intensive. It requires experts to learn from and real-life situations to engage in. This can be challenging in terms of cost, logistics, and availability.
Resource Intensity
Situated learning is often resource intensive. It requires experts to learn from and real-life situations to engage in. This can be challenging in terms of cost, logistics, and availability.
Authenticity in Online Environments
In a world where much of our learning takes place online, creating an authentic experience is challenging. Besides missing out on social interactions and real-time problem-solving, the lack of immersion can make students feel less engaged or inclined to take it seriously.
Transferability
Utilising Situated Learning Theory carries risks such as context dependency, where knowledge may not transfer effectively to different environments.
Applications in Various Fields
Situated learning environments place students in authentic learning situations where they are actively immersed in an activity while using problem-solving (critical thinking) skills. These opportunities should involve a social community which replicates real world situations. In the end, the situated learning experience should encourage students to tap their prior knowledge and to challenge others in their community.
Health Professions Education
Many researchers and educators in the health professions embraced this theory, but few have considered how SLT has been used and what has been learned or improved through its use in health professions education (HPE).
Teacher Preparation
The findings of this study suggest that situated learning theory may provide an effective structure for preparing preservice teachers to integrate technology in ways that support reform‐based instruction.
Workplace Training
Situated learning allows employees to immediately apply what they've learned in the context of performing job-related tasks. Learning occurs among peers who perform the same function. Problem-solving and the generation of new ideas can be better supported in a social learning environment where all of the stakeholders experience the positive effects of ongoing learning. Often, the benefits of situated learning extend well beyond the immediate group of practitioners throughout the organization and the broader community.
Situated Learning in the Digital Age
Technology as a Tool
It is not always possible to facilitate meaningful interactions. Technology has recently become a valuable tool in assisting situational learning. There are many examples of possible situated cognitive activities online, such as case studies or Web-based stimulations. However, these cannot replace valuable, real-life experiences.
Online Learning
Many universities have begun to recognize that authentic situation learning must occur in online courses. While it may be possible for adult learners to gain knowledge and apply theories presented in other learning environments to what they experience in a real-world setting, situated learning offers an opportunity to work with others in considering how to best apply new concepts related to the specific context of their practice.
Web-Based Learning Tools
Web-based learning tools provide integrated environments of various technologies to support diverse educators' and learners' needs via the internet. The goals of these tools are to enhance face-to-face instruction and make distance learning are courses available. Each of these tools offers similar components, such as course note-posting, assignments submission, quizzes, and communication features. The primary motivation for developing these tools is to make it easier for instructors who have very little knowledge of HTML and web navigation to put course materials on the web. There are significant drawbacks as well of using these tools. For example, these systems course instructors and course administrators to use predetermined navigation models and course formats. These constraints may have a negative impact on their flexibility and usability for administrators, teachers, and students. A tool should be as such suitable for diverse courses campus-wide.
Video Games as Learning Environments
… an understanding of video games as learning environments is becoming increasingly important as gaming culture rivals schooling for the attention of children and adolescents across the world. James Paul Gee argues that the compelling nature of video game participation is in part due to the underlying social, cognitive, and developmental learning principles around which successful games are built. Allowing students to have the opportunity to participate, interact and inject their own ideas is a way to obviously grow and make informed decisions. Gee has proven this with the use of video games. It enables the learner to build their social and communication skills as well as develop their cognition abilities. Computer-based learning software such as SimCity has permitted users to utilize situated learning by allowing them to run their own city and become dictators whereby they have to make informed decisions that will either deteriorate their people or help them thrive.
The Broader Impact of Situated Learning
Situated learning is becoming more involved with technology in ways to help individuals learn information differently than they have in the past. The model of learning a skill through technology mimics how individuals learned in the past from a professional in that skill. In the past when individuals learned about a particular topic it was done in person, in a hands-on environment. Technology makes it possible to do these same things using a computer or any other similar device. Interaction through the computer between individuals is one more way to make situated learning more successful as well as give students an opportunity to have another venue through which to learn.
Preparing Students for the Future
When today's students enter their post-education professional lives, odds are pretty good that they will be asked to work with others from around the globe collaboratively to create content for diverse and wide-ranging audiences. When students complete their education, they will be expected to use the skills they have learned throughout their educational career in their professional career. It is imperative that they are able to sufficiently utilize these skills to complete work goals. Through situated learning, students will be able to learn the skills and also be able to accurately use the skills they have learned. Situated learning continues after graduation.
Social and Collaborative Benefits
Situated learning is also heavily reliant on collaborative activities. Students work together and discuss their thinking with other group members. Everyone will bring unique prior knowledge to the situation and are encouraged to challenge the thinking of others. Learning is not independent of the real world but works alongside it.
Practical Implementation of Situated Learning
Just like any other training program, start with a clear identification of the objectives. This should serve as a framework or guideline. As the name implies, context is paramount. Only when activities mimic real-life situations, will learners be able to benefit from the experience.
Creating Authentic Contexts
Select situations that will engage the learners in complex, realistic, problem-centered activities… Situated learning environments place students in authentic learning situations where they are actively immersed in an activity while using problem-solving (critical thinking) skills. These opportunities should involve a social community which replicates real world situations.
Facilitation and Guidance
The instructor should recognize the learning situation as such as become the facilitator or guide in the complex situation. Scaffolding is another tool that instructors can implement in the learning situation. The instructor should be knowledgeable enough to recognize where students may need assistance and what kind of guidance they might need. Instructors are also responsible for assessment, even if the traditional methods of evaluation are not used.
Resource Selection
Videos and visual aids have a natural appeal to learners. Organizations could utilize a host of appropriate resources, as they would in any normal training session. Ensure that every resource is contextual and aids in the problem-solution methodology.
Addressing Common Misconceptions
Universality of Situated Learning
Absolutely not! Situated learning theory is a universal concept and works well across industries and individuals. Do remember to group people of similar skill sets so that learners draw from their collective yet unique experiences.
Alternatives When Situated Learning Isn't Possible
In situations where situated learning is not possible, simulations can offer an alternative way to provide employees with an authentic learning experience.
tags: #situated #learning #theory #explanation
